Guernsey Judgment 53/2003 - Island Development Committee v Lainé & Lainé

View printable version

Island Development (Guernsey) Laws, 1966 to 1990 - Rural Area Plan (Phase 1) - appeal by IDC from decision of the Royal Court - relevant test of unreasonableness to be applied by the Royal Court - margin of appreciation to be allowed to IDC - jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal - adequacy of directions given to Jurats - unlawful extension of the garden did not extend the cartilage of the dwelling for the purpose of applying the policies of the Plan - Jurats should indicate the basis on which they found a decision of the IDC to be reasonable or unreasonable.